Five-Year Swiss Trial Finds Biochar’s Carbon Benefit Depends Heavily on the Farm
21 November 2026, Flaach, CH: A five-year field trial on commercial Swiss farms has found that biochar, a charcoal-like soil amendment often promoted as a reliable way to lock carbon into farmland, raised soil organic carbon on some farms, left it unchanged on another, and lowered it on one more, even though every field received the same material at the same rate.
The study, led by Jens Leifeld of Agroscope, Switzerland’s federal agricultural research institute, and co-author Dilani Rathnayake, also of Agroscope and the University of Peradeniya in Sri Lanka, was published online November 2 and formally issued November 16 in the journal Frontiers in Soil Science. Biochar is produced by heating organic material such as wood in a low-oxygen process called pyrolysis, which converts a portion of its carbon into a highly stable form that resists decomposition in soil for long periods. Because of that stability, biochar has been promoted as a tool for both improving soil and claiming carbon removal credits, but most of the research supporting those claims has come from trials using far higher application rates than most farmers would use in practice.
Leifeld and Rathnayake tested a more realistic scenario: five working arable farms near Flaach, in Switzerland’s Canton Zurich, each applying wood-based biochar at about one tonne per hectare per year for three to five years, for a total of three or five tonnes per hectare. On each farm, a single field was split into two equal halves managed identically except that one half received biochar and the other did not, and researchers tracked soil carbon and nitrogen at 20 marked points per half, down to 60 centimeters, from a 2017 baseline through 2019 and into 2022.
Inconsistent Carbon, but a Possible Nitrogen Saving
Across all five farms combined, the statistical model found no overall increase in soil organic carbon from biochar, and differences between farms accounted for roughly a third of the total variation observed, a sign that farm-specific conditions mattered more than the biochar treatment itself. Three farms showed a statistically significant rise in soil carbon, one farm barely changed, and one farm’s soil carbon fell, in a field that had come out of a three-year grass-clover rotation before biochar was applied. By the final 2022 sampling, however, biochar plots had become significantly higher in carbon than their paired control plots across the trial as a whole, even though the farm-to-farm variation stayed wide. Some control plots without any biochar also gained carbon over the study period, which the researchers attribute to the compost and manure those fields received as part of normal farm management, a reminder that soil carbon responds to a field’s whole fertility program, not to biochar alone.
To understand why some fields gained more carbon than the biochar itself could explain, the team used a heat-based laboratory technique that identifies how resistant different fractions of soil carbon are to breakdown. That analysis suggested that in fields with larger-than-expected carbon gains, the additional material included both biochar’s own stable carbon and a more easily decomposed fraction, such as plant lipids and sugars, while fields with smaller-than-expected gains showed a dip in that same easily decomposed fraction. The researchers describe this evidence as indirect and say confirming it would require isotope tracing, a more precise but more expensive technique not used in this study.
The clearer and more consistent result concerned nitrogen. Across 400 paired samples, control plots needed about 0.10 kilograms of nitrogen for every kilogram of soil organic carbon gained, in line with the typical carbon-to-nitrogen ratio of ordinary soil organic matter. Biochar plots, by contrast, needed only about 0.056 kilograms of nitrogen per kilogram of carbon gained, roughly 44 percent less. Because biochar itself contains relatively little nitrogen compared with its high carbon content, each tonne applied adds bulk carbon without demanding a matching amount of nitrogen from the soil system to stabilize it. Over the full five years, the biochar used in this trial added only about 25 kilograms of nitrogen per hectare in total, a small figure next to the 150 to 200 kilograms per hectare per year of fertilizer nitrogen typically applied on these arable farms.
The authors stop short of recommending biochar as a dependable carbon-sequestration tool, since the direction and size of the soil carbon response could not be predicted from soil type, climate or application rate alone, and a proper side-by-side control was needed on every farm to detect any effect at all. They note that vegetable cropping with frequent tillage and little crop residue returned to the soil, the practice on one of the five farms, showed no carbon benefit from biochar. Farmers in the trial reported no change in crop yield from using biochar over the five years. The researchers describe their work as the first to measure both soil carbon and nitrogen changes together, at depth, under ordinary commercial farming conditions with biochar applied at realistic, rather than experimental, rates.
Also Read: €2.9BN Invested in Biopesticide Innovation, but EU Farmers Still Face Long Waits for New Solutions
Global Agriculture is an independent international media platform covering agri-business, policy, technology, and sustainability. For editorial collaborations, thought leadership, and strategic communications, write to pr@global-agriculture.com







