Food, Nutrition & Wellness

New Grocery Stores Fail to Fix US Food Deserts, Study Finds

19 November 2026, Storrs, US: Opening a new grocery store in a low-income neighbourhood with poor access to healthy food does little to change where local residents shop, according to a nationwide US study that tracked 267 million grocery store visits. Researchers at the University of Connecticut (UConn) and Binghamton University found that a new store gave local shopping trips only a brief lift lasting about a month, and that most of its customers came from outside the neighbourhood it was meant to serve.

The findings, published in the journal Applied Geography and announced by both universities on November 18, 2026, challenge a long-standing assumption behind US food access policy: that the absence of a supermarket is the main reason people in poorer areas eat less healthily.

The US Department of Agriculture (USDA) classifies census tracts as low-income, low-access (LILA) areas, the official term behind what is popularly called a “food desert,” when residents have limited access to healthy and affordable food. Federal programmes, including initiatives tied to the 2014 Farm Bill, have encouraged grocery stores to open in these places.

Tracking shoppers with phone data

The research team, made up of Congcong Miao, assistant professor of geography at Binghamton University, Xiang (Peter) Chen, associate professor of geography, sustainability, community and urban studies at UConn, and Ran Xu, associate professor of allied health sciences at UConn and a public health biostatistician, used anonymised location records from mobile devices to measure actual shopping behaviour rather than store counts or distance.

Live Newsroom

24/7 Live Updates from Across the Globe

The study used a quasi-experimental design, a method that compares a group affected by a change with a similar group that was not, to estimate the change’s effect when a randomised trial is not possible. The researchers identified 112 LILA areas where a new grocery store opened and compared them with 336 areas of similar socioeconomic status where no new store appeared. They then compared residents’ grocery trips before and after each opening, using visits recorded in 2018 and 2019. The universities describe it as the first study to use large-scale human mobility data to evaluate the policy nationwide.

The pattern was consistent. Visits to the new stores peaked during the first month after opening and then fell back. After that first month, the researchers found no significant effect on the grocery shopping of people living in the surrounding food desert. On average, residents of the local LILA area made up less than 20% of visits to the newly opened stores, meaning the majority of shoppers travelled in from elsewhere.

Follow Global Agriculture on WhatsApp
Daily agribusiness news, straight to your phone
Follow Channel

“Just adding a grocery store is not enough to solve the food desert issue,” Xu said in the UConn announcement.

The researchers point to barriers that a new building does not remove. Chen said affordability remains an obstacle for some residents, while others keep using their existing food sources, such as convenience stores, because of dietary habit or cultural preference. Miao said improving access means helping people understand healthy diets and making healthy food more affordable, not only increasing the number of stores.

A shift away from physical access

The results feed a policy debate with direct consequences for food retailers, distributors and the farm sector that supplies fresh produce, dairy and meat to supermarket chains. Much public investment in underserved areas has gone into bricks-and-mortar retail on the assumption that proximity drives purchases. The new evidence suggests that price, habit and food knowledge may weigh more heavily than distance.

Chen said there has been a national de-emphasis on physical food access, and argued that once policymakers know a new store has no lasting effect, federal investment could be redirected toward structural barriers such as high food prices.

The study does not measure what residents bought or ate, only where they shopped, so it cannot show whether diets or health changed. Its window also ends in 2019, before the pandemic and the rise in online grocery ordering and home delivery, which have since changed how many households buy food.

The work was supported by a seed grant from UConn’s Institute for Collaboration on Health, Intervention, and Policy (InCHIP) and by a contribution from UConn alumnus Alan Bennett for public health policy research at the university. The mobility records were drawn from a dataset distributed through the data platform Dewey.

Also Read: Mahindra Launches 50 HP Compact Harvester Harvest Yuva for Small Farms

Global Agriculture is an independent international media platform covering agri-business, policy, technology, and sustainability. For editorial collaborations, thought leadership, and strategic communications, write to pr@global-agriculture.com